Powder Mixing Introduction

Find the answers to all your questions in our Mixing Handbook

Do you have a question, a remark ? Please contact the author at powder.process@protonmail.com

Section summary
1. Principles of mixing
2. Batch mixing vs Continuous mixing
3. Common mixers
Ribbon Blenders
Paddle Mixers
Tumbler Mixers
Ploughshare Mixers

A mixing process is at the heart of many bulk solids processes. Powder or solids mixing allows to get an homogeneous mixture of different component and constitue one of the process steps that adds the more value. However, to mix homogeneously major ingredients with minor ingredients and reach a good homogeneity (measured in practice by a coefficient of variation relative to one of the components used as tracer) is not easy. The page below will guide you through the main industrial blending equipment that exist, their pros and cons and will also introduce the notion of continuous mixing and batch mixing.

The present page is focusing on Dry-Mixing of solids. You may wish to know more about other types of mixing with the following links : Solid / Liquid mixing (slurry) or Liquid / Liquid mixing

Principles of mixing

Froude Number

Powder mixing is based on the movement of the particles part of the recipe to be mixed. The movement can be of different type and different designs of mixers will correspond to different mixing principles.

Mixers are often classified thanks to the Froude number. This adimensional number will define the regime of mixing depending on its value.

Froude number is defined in equation 1 [Perry]:

Froude number for bulk powder blending

Equation 1 : Froude number

With
R = mixer radius or mixer agitator radius
ω = angular velocity

It can be expressed in a more convenient form for powder mixers having a mixing element in equation 2:

Froude number for bulk powder blending

Equation 2 : Froude number calculation for blender equipped with a mixing tool (ribbon, paddles...)

With
u = tip speed mixing element
D = diameter of mixing element

Froude number is comparing 2 forces : Fr = (forces other than gravity - mainly centrifugal) / gravity

If Fr < 1 it means that the gravity forces will be stronger than the centrifugal forces, the powder will remain settled in the mixer, moved, but not in a cloud
If Fr > 1 it means that the centrifugal forces will tend to be stronger than the gravity force : the powder will have a tendency to be suspended in air in the mixer.

Among the common mixers used industrially for powder mixing, the table below is proposing a classification according to Froude number

Table 1 : Mixer classified according to their Froude number and mixing principle

Fr Mixing class Mixer type Pros Cons
< 1 Diffusion Type free fall mixers
V Blenders
Double Cone blenders
Bin blenders
Drums blenders
Very simple
Low energy required
Gentle mix
No mixing elements in the equipment
Reliability
Access for cleaning
Long mixing
Cannot achieve good mixing for powders of very different particle sizes
Segregation effects can be experienced
< 1 Convection Type thrust mixer
Ribbon Blenders
Screw Blenders
Achieve generally better mixing results than diffusion blenders
Low energy inputs
Generally less expensive than paddle or plough share mixers
Long mixing
Mechanical complexity
Access for cleaning
Can damage product at long mixing time
> 1 Convection Paddle Mixers
Pneumatic mixers
Short mixing time
Gentle mixing
Low energy input
Good access for cleaning (some design can be with extractible shafts
For paddle mixers, exist in continuous mixing execution
For padlle mixers, a liquid injection can be foreseen
Cost compared to diffusion tumblers / ribbon blenders
If liquid injection, prone to agglomeration - then needs some additional mixing elements at higher shear
For pneumatically generated fluid bed, attention must be given to risks of segregation due to fines "floating" at the top of the mixer
>> 1 Convection
Shearing
Plough Share Mixers
High shear mixing elements
Short mixing time
Reduce risks of powder agglomeration
Exist in continuous mixing execution
Higher powder breakage
High energy input
Cost

Another type of classification could be proposed depending on the type of process where mixers are integrated : Batch or Continuous. If batch mixer probably represent the majority of the industrial applications, some types of mixers (paddle mixers) can be used in a continuous mode, which can be useful for some kind of processes.

Mixing time

The following elements will influence the mixing time. As a general rule, mixers operators look for a mixing time as short as possible in order to increase the productivity of their line.

Table 2 : parameters influencing the mixing time

Operating parameter Influence on mixing time
Mixing volume A higher mixing volume will lead to higher mixing time
But doubling the volume, does not mean doubling the mixing time
For mixers at Fr>1, after a certain volume, mixing time will be almost constant
Note : a mixer should not be over-filled otherwise the mixing may even become impossible
Mixing speed A higher mixing speed usually gives a shorter mixing time
Influence on the powder should however be considered (powder breakage
Froude number Higher Fr number should give shorter mixing time
Powder breakage will be a concern when Fr >>1
Solids type The more the particle sizes of the mix consituents are different, the more difficult it will be to mix

The influence of the Froude number and the mixer volume are represented in the graph below :

Mixing time of solids blenders

Figure 1 : Mixing time = f(Fr,Volume) [Gericke]

Mixing time is also dependent on the sequence and place of filling the ingredients. In particular, the position of addition of micro ingredients is of prime importance. In case the micro ingredients are added on the side of a mixer, the mixing time can be greatly impacted. As a good practice, processes must be designed to have the small, minor and micro ingredients introduced in the middle of the mixer, in any case in the "active" area of the blender (the fluidization zone for instance).

Batch vs Continuous

Designing a solids mixing process batch or continuous is a question that will be asked at the very beginning of the project since the processes will require very different process equipments.

The principle of operation is radically different. For batch, there will be a discontinuous sequence of preparation, with the dosing of ingredients, then loading to the mixer, then mixing, then discharge of the mixer. This sequence will then be repeated each time a mix must be performed. For continuous process, all happens at the same time and with equipment that differs from the batch in the sense that they are able to dose in continuous the ingredients to the mixer. The mixer is as well able to move the ingredients and mix them at the same time which allows it to operate continuously.

The following grid is summarizing what imply each process type regarding key design parameters

Table 5 : comparison of batch and continuous mixing process

Process variable Continuous Batch
Capacity From 10 kg/h to very large From very small to large
Mixer size (at similar output Smaller Larger
Segregation risks Smaller Higher due to steps following the mixing operation (sudden drop of the material
Space requirements (at similar output) Smaller Larger
Flexibility Lower (continuous mixer designed for few recipe changes Higher (mixing installation can start/stop on demand
Recipe complexity Lower (limited number of ingredients Higher (the process can accomodate more ingredients
Automation Complex for the control of the Loss In Weight Feeders Generally simple
Staff competency required High because of the dosing systems Lower
Space required Comparatively low Comparatively large

Continuous mixing processes need to be supplied continuously in powder by special dosing systems. These dosing systems are made of Loss In Weight feeders. Feeders can use the following feeding units : screw conveyors, vibratory trays or weighing belts. Each feeder is on load cells and must be equipped with a very developped control system allowing to measure the loss of weight over time, filter perturbations, and adjust the feeder speed to keep a given set point in kg/h.

For a continuous mixer, the accuracy of the feeder influences greatly the homogeneity. A continuous blender must be able to provide radial but also axial mixing. In principle, better results will be achieved in plug flow, with minimal axial dispersion. However, if the continuous feeder is not stable, inhomogeneity will be witnessed at the outlet of the continuous mixer. In practice, an axial dispersion is required to cope with the feeder inaccuracies.

Low feeder accuracy will mean that : axial dispersion is required, thus higher mixing volume is required, thus higher mixing time is required.

Common mixers

The following common mixers will be presented below

Ribbon Blender
Paddle mixer
Tumbler mixer

Ribbon Blender

Mixing principle

Ribbon blender

(drawing from US Machinery under license Creative Commons)

Figure 2 : Ribbon blender

Key characteristics

Table 3 : ribbon blender process characteristics

Mixing tool Ribbon
Froude regime less than 1
Typical mixing speeds 50-70 rpm, higher speed can be possible
Size From few 100 l to more than 10000 l
Typical mixing time More than 5 minutes
Impact on product Can be severe if long mixing time at high speed
Number of bearings 2 - mixing tool not cantilevered
Top cover Bolted, with gasket
Outlet 1 - generally round, some design hygienic
Cleanability Limited, not a good access
Access Generally doors on the top
Note : some designs of Ribbon blenders are actually done with an extractible shaft. This promotes cleanability but complexifies the design. The ribbon is anyway difficult to clean.

Paddle Mixers

Mixing principle

Paddle Mixer

Key characteristics

Table 4 : paddle mixer process characteristics

Mixing tool Paddles
Froude regime More than 1
Typical mixing speeds 50 rpm for around 1000 l mixer
Size From few 100 l to 5000 l
Typical mixing time 1 to 2 minutes
Impact on product Mixing is quite gentle, low degradation of powder expected
Number of bearings 1 or 2 - mixing tool can be cantilevered
Top cover Bolted, with gasket or welded
Outlet 1 or 2 - round hygienic design possible, bomb doors possible
Cleanability Good, some design allow to take out the shafts
Access Doors on side, some design with door on front (when cantilered)

Tumbler mixer

Mixing principle

Drum - bin blender

Key characteristics

Table 5 : tumbler mixer process characteristics

Mixing tool Container - V shape, double cone, drum - generally no mixing tool
Froude regime Less than 1
Typical mixing speeds 25 rpm
Size From few l to 2000 l (when containers are mixed)
Typical mixing time 5 to 15 minutes
Impact on product Mixing is quite gentle (if no agitator added), low degradation of powder expected
Number of bearings The drum is agitated by a rotating arm
Top cover Clamped
Cleanability Good when the container is small, poor if bigger, for large container dedication of the container to one product is recommended
Access Mixer must be protected by a safety cage

Type of container blender

Containers can be of very variable size. The smaller blenders will run with drums from few l to 200 liters. Those drums are often made of Stainless Steel, and can be equipped with baffles on the top cover. Those baffles promote the mixing and can result in a reduction in mixing time.

Bigger containers will generally have a conical bottom. Those containers can be 500 to 2000 l big. Some designs can actually be equipped with an agitator. The mixing will then combine the effect of the agitator with the classical avalanche effect of the container rotation



Sources
[Perry] : Perry's 8th Edition, Solids Mixing, 21-39
[Gericke] : adapted from Different Methodes of Batch and Continuous Mixing of Solids, Bulk Solids Handling, H.R. Gericke,1993




Do you want to know more ?
www.powderprocess.net is covering all aspects of solids and powder processing and handling
The pages below will probably interest you !
QUALITY of MIX / MEASURING DEGREE OF MIXING
All you need to know about measuring the degree of mixing (Coefficient of Variation) of a dry mix
SEGREGATION OF POWDERS / DEMIXING
All on the physical phenomena causing segregation of particles and how to avoid them
GRINDING and MILLING
All on main size reduction processes, key equipement, design consideration..etc..
POWDER Properties
All on powder key physical characteristics, among others : flowability, density...etc..
You can find much more through the menus at the top of the page !